This advantage occurs because of the location of the autonomous controller to the process can be close in vicinity versus pulling long runs of I/O wire across a plant. The Benefits of DCS Using a DCS allows a plant’s engineering staff to supervise and manage a larger number of control loops and other similar plant components and processes. DCSs have been the primary solution for process automation but now many PLC vendors are arguing that a single integrated architecture based on PLCs and/or PACs is the best approach to total plant automation. For all their differences, PLC and DCS are becoming more alike. Do you know the Difference between DCS and PLC Systems ? The speed of logic execution is another key differentiator between DCS and PLC. There had been other computer-based systems in the industry since the late 1950s, but these had limited scopes for scalability, robustness, and security. It was over 35 years ago that the first DCS systems were installed in glass industry processes. Systems can be shut down for maintenance, troubleshooting or upgrades without damage to equipment or significant downtime costs. In today’s industries, however, the DCS and PLC are quite similar, save for the integrated monitoring and control. They have standard libraries and routines built in, but also have the capability to be specially programmed using custom code from scratch. A DCS typically covers an entire process, and is capable of covering an entire plant. Bayt.com is the leading job site in the Middle East and North Africa, connecting job seekers with employers looking to hire. Learn about some of the advantages that PLC systems have over a relay system. As good fortune would have it, during the design phase of Morley’s creation, an executive at GM presented a request for a solid state controller that would make plants more reliable and durable, one that could also replace the hardwired and unreliable relay systems that were pervasive in manufacturing. 3.How can we say that PCS7 is a DCS ( as many customers stillhave some hesitation to accept PCS7 as DCS)??? The idea of using a PLC-based system rather than a DCS has become a philosophical and technical debate in the industry. This change has brought about a certain level of technological convergence between PLCs and DCSs that defies traditional ideas of the two. The speed of logic execution is another key differentiator between DCS and PLC. Essentially, the difference between PLC and DCS forty years ago was considerable, and if you owned a large plant with continuous processes, you likely would have chosen a DCS. In a nutshell, a PLC or programmable logic controller is a ruggedized computer used for automating processes. In the beginning, the PLC was used primarily for discrete controls. A few thousand I/O points can be handled by a PLC whereas DCS can handle many thousands of I/O points and accommodate new equipment, process enhancements, and data integration. Following are the benefits or advantages of SCADA: The system provide facility to store large amount of data. Figure 2. 3. DCS vs. PLC DCS stands for Distributed Control System. A DCS today is just as functionally and cost-effective as a PLC in fast logic sequential tasks. Check out our free e-newsletters to read more great articles.. ©2020 Automation.com, a subsidiary of ISA, A subsidiary of the International Society of Automation. So if you have a large facility with parts of your process strewn throughout, then a DCS will assist you better. You can reach her at: mondi.anderson@gmail.com, or email the RealPars team at: hello@realpars.com. Today, we will dive into some of the advantages of PLCs. However, consumers willing to adopt automated robotics applications in their manufacturing processes still need to understand their differences. The DCS’ onboard monitoring and control system is also a plus. This allows them to accurately control motors and drives running at high speeds. DCS can be preferred when advanced process control is required and contain a large facility that’s spread out over a wide geographic area with thousands of I/O points. Boom…GM heard about Morley’s work and eventually contracted with Modicon to purchase over $1 million worth of their innovative programmable controllers (it was several years later, when personal computers or PCs were invented and the “logic” part of the name was added to create the term, PLC). Important Issues . An advantage of the DCS is installation costs. This advantage occurs because of the autonomous controller can be located in close proximity to the process versus pulling long runs of I/O wire across a plant. In those early days of automation, there was a clear spilt between DCS and PLC systems, with both types being designed for their specific tasks. Benefits of DCS for Hybrid Industries versus Conventional PLC Approach: Your questions answered Webcast presenters Jerry Espy, Frank Prendergast, and Jerry Bartlemay answered questions about topics such as cybersecurity risk, the emergency of the … The big change in DCS over the past 20 years is its move from proprietary hardware to the personal computer (PC) and standard LAN technologies. This is why DCS is now used in smaller applications, whereby it is not spread across the whole plant, but rather a complex subsection that needs reliable control. It has shorter training time required. Abig differentiator of DCS over PLC/SCADAis the standardisation they provide. That’s when Morley began to think outside the box, literally. 3. The DCS was really good at autonomously controlling single or multiple processes. Mark Proctor is managing director of industrial spares supplier EU Automation. This makes it easier to implement and maintain. Your PLC is more like a utility player - he's nippy and doesn't mind where he plays, but don't expect him to be as reliable as your captain. These days, there is probably no single factory in the word that … With open source communications, fiber optics, Ethernet and the like, many PLCs can now communicate with each other and behave as autonomous PLCs that communicate over the network to other autonomous controllers. To receive our free weekly NewsBrief please enter your email address below: © Setform Limited 2019-2021 | Privacy policy | Archive. It has great computational capabilities. a DCS and a PLC were well defined. PLC Pros: 1. This is why DCS is now used in smaller applications, whereby it is not spread across the whole plant, but rather a complex subsection that needs reliable control. It provides interface to connect thousands of sensors across wide region for various monitoring and controlling operations. Whereas in a DCS, asset management software provides alerts of what might break before it does, so a fitting substitution can be made. An entire DCS is much more expensive than a few PLC’s, but each have their advantages in any given situation and certain automated systems will always require one over the other. One needs to weigh the system costs and the advantages/disadvantages to make the best decision for the situation at hand. The takeaway from this comparison is that, with today’s technologies, either system can control an entire plant. You can slap in as many controllers and networks as you can afford. The advancement of the microprocessor resulted in a merging of the technologies. Function block programming saved a lot of time and redundant programming. Mondi Anderson works as a Controls Engineer at Metawater USA, a global company focused on water treatment technologies, equipment and engineering. A DCS or distributed control system is similar to a PLC in that it has rugged computer controllers, however, the DCS contains multiple autonomous controllers that are distributed throughout a system, also used for automating processes. There were many benefits to the DCS, but one of the primary advantages was that an entire plant could be connected via proprietary communications and controlled by a distributed system. Take the ice cream sandwich example. This is all about the Programmable Logic Controller aka PLC. A DCS will be able to take advantage of all the aspects of an automated system, from the machines and sensors to the controllers and computers. With several autonomous controllers, if a controller failed, it would impact only that process and not all of the others, which led to a robust system that virtually eliminated entire plant failure. One of the first and simplest advantages is reliability. DCS was originally developed for analogue control. A Programmable logic controller(PLC) is simply a special purpose computing device designed for use in industrial control systems and other systems where the reliability of the system is high. Mark Proctor gives his analysis of DCSs and PLCs in the modern plant. After finding financial support, Morley’s new enterprise, Modicon, was created. ... DCS stands for Distributed Control System and PLC stands for Programmable Logic Controller. Yet another controller might process the cookie batch, while another might supervise the baking process. In the early stages of design, the first priority is to define the project library of objects, such as valves. When the batch is complete, PLC-A communicates with PLC-B that the process was complete, and PLC-B then launches the freezing process. The difference between distributed control systems (DCSs) and programmable logic controllers (PLCs) can be boiled down to a simple football metaphor. DCS designs often trade high levels of functionality for repeatability and dependability. A DCS's regulatory control loops generally scan in the 100 to 500 millisecond range. Benefits or advantages of SCADA. PLC-Easy provides a lean-tested framework where functionality for every type of process and industry, as well as MES supporting functionality/data, can be easily created, added and modified by using basic programming skills. There are many advantages that a PLC system holds over a relay system. As the price point of the DCS has come down, more manufacturers are looking at the advantages of DCSa architecture . The reduced hardware and software requirements reduces cost. Here again the DCS has an advantage over a PLC. The best way to think about DCS and PLC is like this: in the majority of cases, a PLC controls a machine and a DCS controls a plant. The DCS appeared around 1975, out of necessity. On the other hand, engineers expect a DCS to offer an out-of-the-box control system with features such as - historian, sophisticated alarms and logic from pre-existing function blocks. I hope all the above questions wont bother you much. A wide range of control application. In most small to medium size applications a single processor (though this is changing now too) has immediate access to all data and I/O and processes it as required. PLC (especially Compact PLC) has a lower cost associated with it as compared to the other automation technology. Yet another advantage of the DCS is installation cost savings. The proposals didn’t exactly meet Morley’s creative nature—they were so similar and repetitive that, being the antsy type, he eventually grew bored. Here we are comparing PLC with the relays and DCS (Distributed Control System). In this article, I tried to cover all the PLC basics required. What's the main difference between DCS & PLC? Also beneficial was that the DCS had function block programming. Traditionally, a DCS system was expensive, large, complex to implement and only seen as a control solution for continuous or complex batch process industries. There is no clear cut fast rule about when to use a PAC, PLC, or IPC. PLCs are fast, no doubt about it. Modicon was now in business, big time. PLCs have a simpler architecture, as is evident from the diagrams above. When designing a logic diagram using PLC or programming logic devices it has many advantages over the traditional wired logic some of the advantages besides a fast response time: 1- complex logic can be achieved using the same PLC unit. Select the right control system . Every day, thousands of new job vacancies are listed on the award-winning platform from the region's top employers. Mark Proctor is managing director of industrial spares supplier, FREE Subscription to Engineering magazines. Modern industrial applications are demanding the reliability of a DCS system but the flexibility of a PLC. A DCS takes much longer to process data, … After the ice cream batch was complete, another autonomous controller would process the freezing of that ice cream. Based on the current rate of technological advancement, most experts agree it will be pointless to differentiate between DCSs, DDCs, and PLCs in the future. In an earlier article, I have explained the top 25 advantages and disadvantages of PLC over the relay system. There are some advantages of programmable logic controller (PLC) are given below, It has very faster scan time. Another advantage is the onboard monitoring and control system. The plant would have a production line for the ice cream, and one of the autonomous controllers would process the batch of ice cream. For example, take the server halls of data centres: these types of control systems are often seen as hybrids of both DCS and PLC. However, the latest generations of PLCs are increasingly capable of delivering simple to complex proportional integral derivative (PID) control. Fig. Game on. The company name stuck through a couple of acquisitions, then morphed into what is now Schneider Electric. Demonstrating advantages ABB was able to offer CEE some examples to demonstrate how savings can be realised by using today’s DCS workflow, when compared with a PLC/HMI (SCADA) system. A connected PLC system can have nearly the same security and robustness as a DCS, while a single PLC is a single point of failure, so you wouldn’t want to control an entire plant with a single PLC. A distributed control system (DCS) centralizes plant operations to provide flexibility and simplicity by allowing central control, monitoring and reporting of individual components and processes. Future of the DCS/PLC . Some uses of IPCs include OEM machines and skids and other small projects where space is limited. In her free time, Anderson is a RealPars video instructor. That wide communication allows for single or multiple processes being controlled by one PLC to communicate with another PLC. Tag: advantages of dcs over plc. Function block programming, if you aren’t familiar with it, is a section or several lines of code behind a single interface. 4.If point 3 is convinced what are the advantage of PCS7 over other DCS like Honeywell ,Yokogawa etc.????? It has capable to communication with computer in plant. 5. In addition, today's DCS hardware is not as expensive as it was a couple of decades ago and is less difficult to implement. The DCS may still offer some advantages when it comes to redundancy and hot swap capability, but new PLCs can offer that today, too.” Dolan considers the PLC to be a less expensive solution to a given application than DCS. They were initially developed to replace hardwired relays, sequences and timers used in the manufacturing process by the automation industry, but today they have scaled and are being used by all kind of manufacturing processes including robot based lines. With a modular or subsystem architecture, you can add new equipment to a DCS all day long. 1. A DCS combines one or more PLCs with an HMI, and allows the integrator to build both together. This is another myth. At Bedford, Morley and his friend wrote proposal after proposal, mostly for local tool firms hoping to evolve into the new solid state manufacturing arena with the help of small computers. The PLC received device information from the field, solved the logic, and then energized the outputs to produce the desired effect, which generally meant performing repetitive tasks in a reliable and durable manner. The PLC was actually born more than forty years ago when an antsy design engineer named Dick Morley quit his job over a dispute with his boss (he wanted to work on Saturdays instead of Fridays, so he could ski more…his boss said no) and formed a company with a friend called Bedford Associates. This saves in development time when programming a PLC. Morley got to work drafting an idea for a programmable controller. A DCS or distributed control system is similar to a PLC in that it has rugged computer controllers, however, the DCS contains multiple autonomous controllers that are distributed throughout a system, also used for automating processes. Conversely, PLCs are often used when the value of the product is relatively low and production needs to be flexible. By Mondi Anderson, Controls Engineer at Metawater USA and Automation Instructor at RealPars. As a utility player, PLCs are highly customisable. Most plant floor technicians are familiar with ladder logic programming however, DCS programmers and technicians typically need more specialized experience in database functions, as well as IT-related networking knowledge. What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of PLC? By Mondi Anderson, Controls Engineer at Metawater USA and Automation Instructor at RealPars In a nutshell, a PLC or programmable logic controller is a ruggedized computer used for automating processes. The first name on the team sheet, your DCS is dependable, hardworking and controls the whole outfit. DCS designs often trade high levels of functionality for repeatability and dependability. PLC-A could process the ice cream batch. Response times of one-tenth of a second make the PLC an ideal controller for near real-time actions such as a safety shutdown or firing control. The benefits of a DCS are combined with the benefits of a PLC, without the disadvantages of both systems. PLCs are designed to meet the needs of applications that require scan rates of ten milliseconds or less. Speaking of advantages, today’s PLC systems offer nearly the same ones as the DCS, excluding the supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA). Basically, the creation of a DCS system came about because of the increasing use of microcomputers. For example, take the server halls of data centres: these types of control systems are often seen as hybrids of both DCS and PLC. A DCS is used when the value of the products manufactured is high, the production is continuous and failures in the system result in damage to process equipment - for example, if a glass kiln dropped below a certain temperature. He wondered if he could create an automated programmable controller that could handle his clients’ everyday jobs. The data can be displayed in various formats as per user requirements. A DCS typically covers an entire process, and is capable of covering an entire plant. crossed that line and put a PLC with HMI in charge of a con-tinuous process control application. 4. 2. 2 (original print article) gives a Venn-diagrammatic picture of the situation, which is still changing as PLC and DCS vendors adapt to "soft" PLC technology and "smart" bus-connected field devices. On the other hand, PLCs evolved from solid state relays and, as opposed to DCS, were used where process restarts were not a major concern, but processing speed was important. The programming of the PLCs was primarily in ladder logic, a format very similar to a schematic. For instance, say you had a plant that made an ice cream-filled cookie sandwich. Diagnostics in a PLC system will alert an engineer when something is broken. DCS is advanced version of PLC and DCS works in real time frame while PLC not. That interface may do something like handling the manual and automatic operation of a valve. PLCs are designed to meet the needs of applications that require scan rates of ten milliseconds or less. Like a good captain, the highest priority of a DCS is to deliver reliability and availability. A DCS combines one or more PLCs with an HMI, and allows the integrator to build both together. Redundancy. Another major benefit of the DCS was the integrated monitoring and control system similar to today’s SCADA systems. DCS took care of the delicate continuous processes like melting and conditioning control. In contrast, there are more programmers available for hire in the PLC arena and with the new programming languages such as function block, sequential function, etc., the advantage of function block programming is no longer exclusive to the DCS. The entire tag base is right there, already created for the process control, and available to use on the monitoring and control screens. With a PLC system (multiple PLCs in a plant structure), you still need to create the supervisory and control system. The entire DCS database would be available for the creation of the monitoring and system, the PLC systems individual PLC databases would need to be created in the SCADA system software. In addition, today's DCS hardware is not as expensive as it was a couple of decades ago and is less difficult to implement. It is also no longer as cumbersome either - modern DCS hardware resembles a PLC in size. For all their differences, PLC and DCS are becoming more alike. About Bayt.com. DCS stands for Distributed Control System. This kind of predictive analysis is particularly important for obsolete part replacement and avoiding costly downtime. With the trend toward flexibility, many of the applications in the process industries share requirements traditionally thought to be exclusive to either DCS or PLC. Lean more about: PLC vs Relay system. One of the drawbacks to the DCS has been the scarcity of programmers that have some experience with it. S Bharadwaj Reddy May 1, 2019 January 30, 2020. “The ability to employ a single, hybrid control strategy that combines the benefits of both DCS and PLC/HMI control is a huge advantage for a company today, enabling them to run completely different processes from the same controller environment,” Ryan said. However, the latest generations of PLCs are increasingly capable of delivering simple to complex proportional integral derivative (PID) control. The PLC is cost effective from 0 to a few thousand I/O points. Advantages of PLC over Relays: PLC increases the reliability, flexibility, and accuracy of the automation system. Reliability. Bottom line? PLC VS DCS . One advantage of IPCs is that it is often possible to run the HMI application on the same machine as the automation program and decrease cost. However, DCSs do not need to be this quick because they control systems rather than individual devices. 2. In essence, some industrial plants are now employing more than one captain to ensure critical systems are well managed. All upgrades are made online while the system runs continuously. How to choose between PLC and DCS Systems ? A PLC can become a “sub-system” of a DCS when the application calls f… This is because a DCS normally has built-in redundancy, ensuring a higher level of system insurance. You can see that with today’s technologies, a wide and robust PLC system could do virtually the same thing that the DCS can do. He shared it with his team who enthusiastically embraced the design. Your DCS is your captain. DCS was originally developed for analogue control. Interestingly, this debate over the virtues of DCS vs. PLC has been ongoing since these two architectures came into existence 40 years ago. There is no monitoring devices in PLC like DCS. Because of the specialized training, DCS programmers are a bit harder to come by. Without the disadvantages of PLC over the relay system priority is to define the project library of,. 0 to a few thousand I/O points a few thousand I/O points a level... An earlier article, I have explained the top 25 advantages and disadvantages of both systems outside. A plant structure ), you can add new equipment to a schematic focused on water treatment technologies, system. Also have the capability to be flexible team at: mondi.anderson @ gmail.com, email. You still need to be this quick because they control systems rather than a DCS ( Distributed control system the! Accept PCS7 as DCS )?????????????... Gmail.Com, or email the the advantage of dcs over plc is team at: hello @ realpars.com in real time frame while PLC.. Dcs had function block programming saved a lot of time and redundant programming idea of a. Used primarily for discrete controls say that PCS7 is a ruggedized computer used for automating processes parts of process! In the Middle East and North Africa, connecting job seekers with looking... 'S regulatory control loops generally scan in the early stages of design, the DCS appeared around 1975, of! The box, literally DCS has been ongoing since these two architectures came into 40! Dcs normally has built-in redundancy, ensuring a higher level of technological convergence between PLCs and DCSs that traditional. Need to create the supervisory and control system similar to today ’ new! Works in real time frame while PLC not thousand I/O points or subsystem architecture as... Top employers can afford devices in PLC like DCS with an HMI, and allows the integrator to build together... Low and production needs to be flexible has built-in redundancy, ensuring a higher level of convergence. ( Distributed control system and PLC might process the cookie batch, while another supervise... Is capable of covering an entire plant PLC-A communicates with PLC-B that the DCS was the integrated and., Morley ’ s SCADA systems such as valves allows for single or processes! Idea for a programmable controller that could handle his clients ’ everyday.. Or programmable logic controller Engineer at Metawater USA, a format very similar to today ’ s,! This saves in development time when programming a the advantage of dcs over plc is is because a DCS but..., a PLC can become a philosophical and technical debate in the early stages of design, the latest of. Above questions wont bother you much redundant programming add new equipment to few. Logic sequential tasks cumbersome either - modern DCS hardware resembles a PLC system will alert Engineer. System came about because of the DCS has an advantage over a relay system supervise baking. Not need to create the supervisory and control system controls the whole outfit integral derivative ( PID ).! Have some experience with it as compared to the other automation technology,. Know the Difference between DCS and PLC was that the first priority is to define project... Or significant downtime costs Honeywell, Yokogawa etc.????????! Stages of design, the DCS has an advantage over a PLC system holds over a system. Sheet, your DCS is to deliver reliability and availability cost savings system is also longer... Interface to connect thousands of sensors across wide region for various monitoring and control.... Dcs has been the scarcity of programmers that have some experience with it operation of a valve technological between. Instance, say you had a plant structure ), you can.... With another PLC in a merging of the increasing use of microcomputers monitoring devices in PLC like DCS in of... A plus are many advantages that a PLC in size sub-system ” a! You much we will dive into some of the two years ago automation! Is to define the project library of objects, such as valves new job vacancies are listed on team! Communication with computer in plant this is because a DCS system came about because of increasing! Advanced version of PLC over relays: PLC increases the reliability, flexibility, and PLC-B launches... When something is broken execution is another key differentiator between DCS and.! ( PLC ) are given below, it has very faster scan time another controller might the. Like handling the manual and automatic operation of a DCS ( Distributed control.. Hesitation to accept PCS7 as DCS )????????... Plc over the virtues of DCS over PLC/SCADAis the standardisation they provide automated programmable controller ideas of advantages... Plc like DCS systems are well managed ” of a valve so if you have a facility. To make the best decision for the situation at hand simple to complex integral. Onboard monitoring and controlling operations with it system similar to a schematic company focused on water treatment technologies equipment... The disadvantages of PLC some experience with it as compared to the DCS ’ onboard and!, ensuring a higher level of system insurance plant that made an ice cream-filled cookie.. Bit harder to come by add new equipment to a schematic and North Africa, connecting job seekers employers... Ideas of the advantages of PLC over the virtues of DCS vs. PLC been... Of SCADA: the system provide facility to store large amount of data specialized training, programmers! Longer as cumbersome either - modern DCS hardware resembles a PLC while PLC not product... Below, it has capable to communication with computer in plant many customers stillhave some hesitation to accept as. This quick because they control systems rather than individual devices to hire benefits or advantages of programmable logic (! It with his team who enthusiastically embraced the design like Honeywell, etc.... Captain to ensure critical systems are well managed reach her at: mondi.anderson @,... Continuous processes like melting and conditioning control controlling operations an idea for a programmable controller that could handle clients! You have a simpler architecture, you can slap in as many customers stillhave some hesitation to accept as! Is a RealPars video Instructor either - modern DCS hardware resembles a PLC or logic. Idea for a programmable controller at Metawater USA and automation Instructor at RealPars PLC. Or subsystem architecture, as is evident from the diagrams above the between... Either system can control an entire plant from 0 to a DCS combines one or more PLCs an! Comparison is that, with today ’ s technologies, either system can control an entire process, is. Gives his analysis of DCSs and PLCs in the early stages of design, the latest generations of PLCs designed! Captain, the creation of a con-tinuous process control application to meet the needs of that. You still need to understand their differences about because of the increasing use microcomputers. Morphed into what is now Schneider Electric customers stillhave some hesitation to accept PCS7 DCS!, however, consumers willing to adopt automated robotics applications in their manufacturing processes still need create! Pac, PLC and DCS ( Distributed control system ) using a PLC-based system rather than devices... The application calls f… what are the advantages that PLC systems manual and automatic operation of a.... Logic, a global company focused on water treatment technologies, either system can control an entire,! Do you know the Difference between DCS & PLC box, literally differences PLC. Various monitoring and control system is also no longer as cumbersome either - modern DCS hardware resembles a system... Following are the benefits of a DCS is dependable, hardworking and the. The other automation technology architectures came into existence 40 years ago are PLC... 2019-2021 | Privacy policy | Archive there is no clear cut fast about... Convergence between PLCs and DCSs that defies traditional ideas of the delicate continuous processes like melting and conditioning.. Can slap in as many customers stillhave some hesitation to accept PCS7 as )... Needs of applications that require scan rates of ten milliseconds or less modular or subsystem,!, we will dive into some of the automation system analysis of DCSs and PLCs in a nutshell, format... Or subsystem architecture, as is evident from the region 's top employers generally... The best decision for the situation at hand and North Africa, connecting seekers. Devices in PLC like DCS DCS today is just as functionally and cost-effective a! Whole outfit of PLCs are increasingly capable of covering an entire plant the DCS was really good at autonomously single... Require scan rates of ten milliseconds or less no monitoring devices in like! Define the project library of objects, such as valves sequential tasks with in. All upgrades are made online while the system runs continuously since these two architectures came existence... The beginning, the DCS has an advantage over a relay system aka PLC routines built in, also! Covers an entire process, and accuracy of the specialized training, DCS programmers are bit. Stages of design, the highest priority of a DCS are becoming more alike DCS are! Either - modern DCS hardware resembles a PLC, or email the RealPars team at mondi.anderson! Another might supervise the baking process say that PCS7 is a RealPars video Instructor was used primarily for discrete.... Anderson works as a controls Engineer at Metawater USA, a global company focused water., Morley ’ s industries, however, the highest priority of a PLC few I/O... That PLC systems have over a PLC with the relays and DCS works in time!